Ed (To Posts 16 and 19): I fully agree with what you say and thanks for requesting my opinion. I am also convinced that bad ideas must be attacked, in spite of then running the risk of suffering a personal physical assault, as it happens with the Danish Mohammed cartoonists. The least that will happen is a totally furious reply as has just happened with Claude Shannon's reply on Post 25 of "Religion is Totalitarian" [http://rebirthofreason.com/Forum/GeneralForum/1185_1.shtml#23] to my comment on Post 22 of the mentioned thread. Objectivism and Objectivists cannot expect any better from people that lack arguments as soon as they're out of their depths, and they immediately are, for they belong to that part of the human population that the Arab Abu'l-`Ala' al-Ma`arri (973 - 1057) classified as follows: "The inhabitants of the earth are of two sorts: Those with brains, but no religion, and those with religion, but no brains."
Such attacks, which are typical to all religions (as well as to many political movements, such as, for example, the Nazis and the Communists) characterize their intellectual inferiority, since they evidence their lack of any convincing arguments by resorting to violence. Further on, both the threat and the carrying out of violence to shut dissenting voices continuously blocks both the advance of new ideas and what I would call the progress of progress itself.
As history shows, it is this that has prevented mankind's advancement towards a general well-being for the general population, and only favored the commanding coterie involved. Moreover, this delay, which also involves scientific evolution, can easily mean the destruction of the whole planet (incoming asteroids and such). I took up this subject in my book "Ayn Rand, I and the Universe", which was published by "Rebirth of Reason", for which I will always be grateful. Charles Freeman clearly analyzed Christianity's obstruction to science and general progress in his book ""The Closing of the Western Mind". As I mention in my reply to Claude Shannon (Post 28 of "Religion is Totalitarian" - http://rebirthofreason.com/Forum/GeneralForum/1185_1.shtml#23) Objectivism presents a totally different option to the world.
Thus, overcoming this habit of throwing threats and using violence to obtain one's aims will be, as I see it, the final confrontation with the up to now existing root of human societies (See http://rebirthofreason.com/Articles/Schieder/Ayn_Rand_and_Rational_Egoism_The_dynamo_of_human_progress.shtml). Evidently, defending what is right can, unfortunately, be very costly in every sense.
|