| | In a dissertation, yes; in a TV script, I'm not so sure. The writer liked the line, and he gave credit where credit was due. Taking time out for footnotes would have made for some conspicuously clunky dialogue. If this easy-to-misinterpret quote were part of an extensive pattern you'd be right. Why does it have to be part of an extensive pattern? Toohey was a character in one of Rand's novels. If that character were espousing her philosophy, fine. But in this case, he was espousing its exact antithesis. To say, without any further explanation, that Rand said this implies that it was one of her views, especially since she is not only a novelist, but a philosopher with a very radical set of ideas.
The reference didn't require a footnote. All it required was the crediting of Toohey as one of Rand's characters -- to wit,
Quoting Ellsworth Toohey, from Ayn Rand's novel, The Fountainhead: "We are all brothers under the skin. And I, for one, would be willing to skin all of humanity to prove it." What's so clunky about that?
- Bill
|
|