| | Hi Sam!
Thanks for the insight! As I said previously there were lots of reasons I thought people might not like the movie, but wasn't sure which it was for the most part.
Maybe we understood the movie differently, so I'll explain why I didn't think they implied man's mind is mechanical, but actually the opposite. They didn't 'reprogram' Alex's mind. They initiated a Pavlov's dog type response in him instead. When he watched movies of violence and such, they gave him drugs that would make him violently ill. That's why the unintentional side-effect of him not being able to listen to Beethoven's 9th came about (which wasn't intentionally 'reprogrammed'). They didn't program him not to want to rape and fight, in fact he still very much wanted to do so, they made it so when he went to act on his urges he became violently sick and so had to choose between going through with it in such pain or ending the sickness and not raping or fighting, even fighting to defend himself against attack.
The doctors saw it as "fixing" him, and the priest fought against it saying that in taking away his power to choose bad (over good), they are robbing him of the chance to choose his own actions, hence he is no longer really a man because he now lacks the power to act on free will.
The author made it so that the villain had no redeeming qualities. So if they had sentenced him to death, chances are you wouldn't care much. But instead they did something that to society might have seemed more "humane", after all he was still able to function in society, but to others it was worse than killing him. It was keeping him alive but taking away that one thing that made him a man, versus something mechanical. And I think that's why the title is Clockwork Orange and it's what I got out of the author's description for the choice. Not that man is mechanical, but that if you take away this power to make choices, and "automate" man's reactions, than he is then no longer a man but rather a mechanical toy.
I don't know how realistic that is, but there are certain things that I look at now that make me slightly ill due to memories of having been really sick from them in the past. Or cancer patients sometimes vomit at a certain smell or running into their old oncologist from the memories of when they were sick. This was taking that idea to the extreme of using these memory reflexes to program actions.
Didn't mean to drag this out, this isn't the best movie ever and maybe others are more worthy to talk about, but because there are many questions, implications and interpretations in the movie, I was very much curious what others got out of it! So thanks again for letting me know why you didn't like it!
-Elizabeth
(Edited by Elizabeth on 6/24, 9:05am)
|
|