| | Here is a question I posed last year on the general yahoo forum with no result. Does anyone know what Rand's comments on Orwell's "1984" were? In her book, "the art of fiction" she merely lists "1984" together with "Atlas Shruuged" and "Anthem" as example of fantasy writing. Not that she commented on it, but she didn't say anything negative - nor did she list it seperately. In the style of the rest of the book, it would be unusual for her not to say something strongly negative about "1984", if she had thought so. Linz tells me that Rand was critical of the idea that a totalaterien society like that of "big brother" would be able to develop advanced technology to monitor their own citizens. (Nevertheless, I think that Orwell implies that the corupt regime may have only inherited the technology from an earlier Government or Revolutionary Regime. Remember all the depressing dust and decay that is pervading around Winston Smith? Also, there is still some transition taking place during even Winston's time towards the ultimate big brother "state".) However, I can't find Rand's quote anywhere. I have easily found her comments on "Animal Farm" in her letters, but not anything about "1984".
In case, no one can help out on this front, maybe you would like to comment on Rand's admiration of the works of Oscar Wilde and Tchaikovsky? Anyone? She mentions in the "art of fiction" that "the importance of being earnest" is an example of benevolent fiction.
|
|