In fact, Gwen Ives does break down into laughter when Rearden refuses Dr. Potter's offer to buy a shipment of Rearden Metal. That aside, Gwen Ives was not the only one who was ruthlessly efficient at work or lacking in spontaneous emotion. Rearden is saddened to learn that Ken Dannager called him "the only man I ever loved" because Dannager's only words to him were on the order of "look, here, Rearden." Being Rand herself, Dagny Taggart did express her emotions, the sum of her conscious thoughts as instanteous value judgments. She laughs, she cries, she chills into anger. No one else does in the course of their working day. The characters in Atlas Shrugged did not have the range of depth that Rand gave to the characters in The Fountainhead. The latter opens with, "Howard Roark laughed." Mike Donnigan has no corollary in Atlas. The analog to Steven Mallory would be the Wet Nurse, Tony, but the differences between them are fundamental. Allow me to coin the term "psycho-metaphysical." I mean a quality different than "sense of life"but rather the total possible range of actions of which a person is capable. In The Fountainhead, Mallory and Dominique developed an easy working relationship. Although Gwen Ives married Eddie Willers in a fanfic universe, even within that universe it would have been impossible for them to go out for a drink after work. The answer to Chris Baker is that it would be wrong for the same reason that Dagny could never have slept with Eddie Willers. As much as they shared in sense of life, their psycho-metaphysical natures were vastly different. That is what made the relationship between James Taggart and Cheryl Brooks wrong and ultimately ironic. An efficient shop girl might keep the inventory of one store in order. As the CEO of a transcontinental railroad, he was supposed to have all of that in his head -- which Dagny did: her conceptual range was orders of magnitude beyond Cheryl Brooks', moral and commendable as Brooks was. James Taggart just made himself dumber, considering less and less, as the plot progressed. He was not even a wiley looter. (Edited by Michael E. Marotta on 6/19, 4:16pm)
|