About
Content
Store
Forum

Rebirth of Reason
War
People
Archives
Objectivism

Post to this threadMark all messages in this thread as readMark all messages in this thread as unread


Post 0

Tuesday, August 28, 2012 - 8:19amSanction this postReply
Bookmark
Link
Edit
So what else is new?

Post 1

Tuesday, August 28, 2012 - 8:58amSanction this postReply
Bookmark
Link
Edit

Lovely piece, Merlin. Even the words of Rand at the end, so wrong said against so many, are so right in this case.

Thanks!

Post 2

Tuesday, August 28, 2012 - 9:02amSanction this postReply
Bookmark
Link
Edit
Dr. Binswanger's column was a good read. But it comes close to implying that Ryan has called himself an Objectivist. He has never called himself an Objectivist - what he took from Ayn Rand was a political system that is much closer to what we used to have - individualism instead of collectivism, but he has always been a Catholic. In other words, he is a strong supporter of some of what Rand advocated, but not everything.

The other thing to understand is that we are restrained in the speed at which we could move towards full capitalism by the Overton Window. There is over 100 years of Progressive propaganda to be reversed before the voting population would be ready to demand full Capitalism - that doesn't have to take 100 plus years, but it wouldn't be likely to happen faster than the time it takes to move a couple of generations through an improved college system.

I'd like to think that a culture has the ability to change at near the speed of communications and thought and that a set of ideas could take root in mere months... but I don't see what would make that happen in this context. So, I see Ryan as someone who, along with Rand Paul and Mike Lee and a few others in Washington as being as far as it is possible to be to the right and still fall within the Overton Window - and thereby able to get elected, have their ideas put into place, and in doing so they are a force for moving the window to the right.

Dr. Binswanger describes where we want to go, and that kind of intellectual leadership is needed, but we also need to understand that there are limits as to how fast, or how many steps will be taken before we get there.


(Edited by Steve Wolfer on 8/28, 9:04am)


Post 3

Tuesday, August 28, 2012 - 5:00pmSanction this postReply
Bookmark
Link
Edit
I agree that Dr. Binswanger nicely summarized some of the many essential differences between Objectivism and whatever else Republican politicians might believe in.  As Yaron Brook pointed out, many people - millions - were "influenced" by the works of Ayn Rand, and (we Objectivists like to believe) all for the better. 

I believe that the appearance of Ayn Rand's name and ideas - even severely misstated and perniciously misrepresented - is not a coincidence, but a direct consequence of the correctness of those ideas. 

Steve also nicely drew the lines of tension connecting the emergence of new ideas and their acceptance. Realize though, that in science as in politics, we do have revolutions.  Thomas Kuhn pointed out that paradigms fail when the experiments they commanded result in facts which they cannot explain. 
("Stagflation" and the failures of FRB policies, the failures of public schooling despite ever-increasing funds all come to mind easily. ) 

Suddenly, a new idea springs forward, though it was slow in developing and not perceived.  Kuhn, like Keynes, said that in the long run, the advocates of the old paradigm give way to a new generation.  I believe that it was John Adams who said that the real American revolution took place 1765 to 1775, as people developed a new way to see themselves, even changing their religious orientation - being willing to forgoe the idea of a national church - before the Declaration was possible.

The presidency of Barack Obama was not a leftwing dictatorship at all, but only the continuation of policies from the Bush era... ever more epicycles to save the phenomenon....

The very fact that Harry Binswanger could post that in Yahoo Finance as a primary blog item speaks volumes to the change that is coming.


Post to this thread


User ID Password or create a free account.