I had no idea who John Cage was. I found several performances on YouTube. "I've Got a Secret (1954)" Water Walk for Bathtub, Rubber Duckie, etc.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yybn6iKmYdQ 13 Harmonies (of 42 in the piece) [Minimalist, but recognizable as music -- MEM] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BowyUXyNud4 Ocean of Sound [Again minimalist, but still music -- MEM] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ShH-Td3ZiKs I qualify Water Walk as performance art, not music. We always experience a tension, perhaps a conflict, between the intention of the artist and the perception of the viewer or listener. On Galt's Gulch Online, I said that conservatives perceive Atlas Shrugged as a political novel, when in fact, it is a love story. That brought angry exclamation points, but Scott Despasio weighed in with a quote from Ayn Rand. Regarding the "Richard Halley" performance in AS2, some in the Gulch objected to the modernistic dissonance as inappropriate or even ignorant of Rand's own intentions regarding Halley as a modern Rachmaninoff. However, if you listen to enough Rachmaninoff, you can hear those, as well. In fact, you can find them in Beethoven, whom Rand regarded as anti-life, again a conflict between the composer and the audience. It is easy to dismiss Cage, and I do not have much invested in him, but I point to Terry Riley's In C, and other works that explore how little we need to convey information.
|