[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Rebirth of Reason

Post to this threadMark all messages in this thread as readMark all messages in this thread as unread

Post 0

Sunday, January 16 - 7:29amSanction this postReply
I saw this yesterday and liked it. It surprised me that so good a movie could be made from such a small topic. The acting was excellent.

A technical note: The person played by Helena Bonham Carter was queen consort but never queen regnant. Her daughter Elizabeth became queen regnant and still reigns.

Post 1

Monday, February 7 - 9:05amSanction this postReply
Peter, thank you! 

After your review, I tried for over a month to see the movie.  One thing after another prevented us.  The night before last, following the snow of the previous night, the city came through with their scrapers and sealed us in again -- it took an hour to clear the driveway of the compacted ice.  It's always something... 

Last night my wife and I finally made it.  We were both glad we did.    The movie was everything you said, and more.  Director Tom Hooper did a masterful job of holding our attention -- a word rooted in "tension" -- without a single gun or naked body in the whole movie.  It was a talkie about talking.  I have to credit Colin Firth for being an actor in an age of "types" in which stars and starlets play themselves (or their screen persona) over and over.  Firth became someone else.  

(Guy Pearce has a natural similitude to Edward VIII, but judging from other stills, not so much as he was born with, as he projected.  I agree that Queen Elizabeth as portrayed by Helena Bonham Carter was charming for her intelligent wit.)

The contrast between Albert ("Bertie") King George VI and Lionel Logue is deep; but they bridge it and it is to the king's credit, of course, as Logue can do little more than try once to see him (while is still the Duke of York) and fail.  The initiative must rest with the king who is faced with a complex matrix of inter-related problems.  In an age of radio, his stammer is a state problem. He cannot remain in the background: his brother's ridiculous romance and subsequent abdication forces him to the front.  And his nation is threatened by a war brought to them by a masterful orator who does understand the power of speech, even by radio. 

This is not My Fair Lady.  Albert does indeed improve his speech.  He can talk much better in more circumstances.  But he could not have delivered his first wartime speech but for the immediate coaching of Lionel Logue ... and still he stammers a bit.  ("Rough at first, but better toward the end," says his daughter, Princess Elizabeth.)

For me, this was about two men from different cultures brought together to solve a problem.  For my wife, it was all about public speaking.  Most people would rather be in a roomful of spiders than in front of an audience.  Many people say they fear death less than they fear public speaking.  She is one of those.  I am not. Thursday night, I spoke on "Monetary Media as Astronomical Record" to the astronomy club of my alma mater.  I was in my element.   So, for me, the deep and abiding value in this movie - its metaphysical reward - was in the abstraction of highly consequential conflict overcome by the shared self interests of two intelligent people.

(Edited by Michael E. Marotta on 2/07, 9:12am)

Post 2

Monday, February 7 - 10:10amSanction this postReply
it can also be seen here -


Post 3

Monday, February 7 - 10:45amSanction this postReply
See the last sentence of the original review.  Watching it on a computer screen would be esthetically and perhaps legally criminal.

Post 4

Sunday, December 18 - 7:58amSanction this postReply
The King Speaks (Amazon here) produced by Philip Armstrong-Dampier for BFS Entertainment (details on IMDB here) as The Real King's Speech.  (50 minutes)

This documentary at once removes some of the fiction and also reinforces the drama of the movie.  Providing archival film, it shows the agony that Albert (George VI) suffered and also his triumph in rising above it. Official fims were edited before distrbution.  Here you sit through the pauses and stammers.  Commentaries from students of Lionel Logue deliver background on the techniques. 

Post to this thread
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

User ID Password or create a free account.